Friday, December 31, 2004

fresh air

After a week of family gatherings and summer job application filings (which has rekindled the whole what do I want to do with my life question), I'm darting south early tomorrow morning for a week of off-piste skiing in the Chamonix Valley (France, you stupide americaines) with my brothers. Olof is going to be sticking to the slopes, but Martin and I are booked for a week of guided backcountry hotness. Here's hoping I return in one peice.

Saturday, December 25, 2004

Hedonic Adaptation

In an article in MIT Technology Review, James Surowiecki asks, "is it possible that technology, instead of liberating us, is holding us back? Is technological progress merely a treadmill, and if so, would we be happier if we stepped off of it?" A solid read, touching on Jacques Ellul (Frenchie) and Robert Putnam (author of Bowling Alone).

Halftime Report: Science 27, Politics 0

The closing money-shot from an article on genetically engineered cocaine in Wired:
...found no evidence of modification. He tested specifically for the presence of CP4 - a telltale indicator of the Roundup Ready modification - as well as for the cauliflower mosaic virus, the gene most commonly used to insert foreign DNA into a plant. It is still possible that the plant has been genetically modified using other genes, but not likely. Discovering new methods of engineering glyphosate resistance would require the best scientific minds and years of organized research. And given that there is already a published methodology, there would be little reason to duplicate the effort.

Which points back to selective breeding. The implication is that the farmers' decentralized system of disseminating coca cuttings has been amazingly effective - more so than genetic engineering could hope to be. When one plant somewhere in the country demonstrated tolerance to glyphosate, cuttings were made and passed on to dealers and farmers, who could sell them quickly to farmers hoping to withstand the spraying. The best of the next generation was once again used for cuttings and distributed.

This technique - applied over four years - is now the most likely explanation for the arrival of Boliviana negra. By spraying so much territory, the US significantly increased the odds of generating beneficial mutations. There are numerous species of coca, further increasing the diversity of possible mutations. And in the Amazonian region, nature is particularly adaptive and resilient.

"I thought it was unlikely," says Gressel, the plant scientist at the Weizmann Institute. "But farmers aren't dumb. They obviously spotted a lucky mutation and propagated the hell out of it."

The effects of this are far-reaching for American policymakers: A new herbicide would work only for a limited time against such a simple but effective ad hoc network. The coca-growing community is clearly primed to take advantage of any mutations.

A genetic laboratory is not as nimble. A lab is limited by research that is publicly available. In the case of Fusarium, the coca-killing fungus and likely successor to glyphosate, there is no body of work discussing genetically induced resistance. If the government switched to Fusarium, a scientist would have to perform groundbreaking genetic research to fashion a Fusarium-resistant coca plant.

The reality is that a smoothly functioning selective-breeding system is a greater threat to US antidrug efforts. Certainly government agents can switch to Fusarium and enjoy some short-term results. But after a few years - during which legal crops could be devastated - a new strain of Fusarium-resistant coca would likely emerge, one just as robust as the glyphosate-resistant strain.

The drug war in Colombia presupposes that it's eventually possible to destroy cocaine at its source. But the facts on the ground suggest this is no longer possible. In this war, it's hard to beat technology developed 10,000 years ago.

Tuesday, December 21, 2004

words, words, words

Another two-fer.

An article on the Google book inventory project and a complimentary article on the future of libraries (as places of worship).

Last night I stumbled across an incomplete collection of Shakespeare as commented by my amatuer-Shakespeare-scholar great aunt. They are the most elaborately commented books I have ever seen. Underlined in four different colors, in different thicknesses, lines connecting sections drawn with rulers, inserted newspaper clippings regarding performances, an index of favorite passages, references to different translations, folio versions, et al. Crazy impressive. The sad part is that she died before I was born, and I really wish i had met her. I've heard stories through the family...she was the eldest daughter to my great grandfather, and allowed to complete high school, but then told that women don't attend university. So she worked as a secretary all her life while reading feverishly in her private life. Upon retiring, she enrolled at Stockholm University and studied English Literature, then Linguistics, then Phonetics, and finally Accoustics at the Engineering College. So sad, too cool.

Monday, December 20, 2004

"A Nation of Wimps"

There's a new word in Sweden that's all the rage: curlingparents. It's used to refer to parents that pave the way for the children similar to how curlers (is that what you call them?) scuff and smooth the ice for the rock in curling. I find it very amusing...and I was reminded of it by two recent article on child rearing that look at the problems of over-protection and over-prescription.

The first is on article in Psychology Today on parental hyperconcern, which I feel is a huge problem for today's youth. It was particularly apparent in my (county-wide science magnet) high school in New Jersey. It is also rather directly addressed by the educational model of Deep Springs.

The article discusses the 'all-rubber-cushioned surface playgrounds' showing up across America, one of which was installed behind my elementary school just as I moved on up. I am incredibly grateful to have graduated from the 'school of hard knox' playground model, where I skinned my knees and fashioned permanent grass stains into most of my wardrobe.

You can't just bubblewrap a kids life in an effort to protect him. Life doesn't work like that, and there's plenty of evidence from immunology and developing immune systems that clearly demonstrate the benefits of wide exposure.

And that's largely what Deep Springs is about: being handed enormous responsibility and being held brutally accountable for the whole she-bang. Learning to fail. Learning to be accountable for your own actions, your own life.

The article proposes that this is somewhat responsible for the current state of college drinking, "it gives young people something all their own to talk about, and sharing stories about the path to passing out is a primary purpose. It's an inverted world in which drinking to oblivion is the way to feel connected and alive."

It also looks at grade inflation, the disappearance of recess, cell phones, etc. Really good observations. On cell phones:
Think of the cell phone as the eternal umbilicus. One of the ways we grow up is by internalizing an image of Mom and Dad and the values and advice they imparted over the early years. Then, whenever we find ourselves faced with uncertainty or difficulty, we call on that internalized image. We become, in a way, all the wise adults we've had the privilege to know. "But cell phones keep kids from figuring out what to do," says Anderegg. "They've never internalized any images; all they've internalized is 'call Mom or Dad.'"

There's also a point that I've been making for a long time, that cell phones encourage kids to forgo planning, to not think ahead. I remember getting really annoyed at friends who got cell phones near the end of high school because they practically refused to make plans..."I'm going out to dinner with my girlfriend, but I'll call you when I'm done and maybe we can meet up."

Last but not least it looks at the American tendency to freight-train through highschool/internships/college/professionalism. "There's decent historical evidence to suggest that societies that allow kids a few years of latitude and even moderate [rebellion] end up with healthier kids than societies that pretend such impulses don't exist."

One part that I disagree about is the criticism of a Dr. Suess childhood. There's nothing wrong with telling your kids that they can accomplish anything as long as you let them learn the process of accomplishment rather than hand them prefabricated success. Of course they're going to crash and burn if they've never had to work for it. A book like Oh the Places You'll Go! is supposed to show kids what they can do if they put their heart into it. A good message. It's only wrong if their parents are putting the heart and they're being chauffeured to the places.

The other article of note was about Big Pharm's push of ADHD drugs onto the youth of America. It interviews former scientists-turned-industry whores who've been doing bunk research for drug companies.
Between 1997 and 1999, he was paid by McNeil to conduct one of three studies used to get FDA approval. The company currently uses the three studies to claim that 96 percent of children taking Concerta experience no problems in appetite, growth, or sleep. But Pelham says the studies were flawed. The original intent of the studies was to measure both side effects and main effects of the drug. But two of the three studies, including Pelham's, required that the subjects had to already be taking MPH and responding well to it in order to enter the study. In other words, by stacking the studies with patients already successfully taking stimulants, McNeil ensured the subjects would be unlikely to register side effects, Pelham says.

This stuff is really scary, consider that in 10 years it won't be just ritalin but EUPHORIA (tm), and half of american children will be walking around mindless soldier of glee. Be afraid.

---

And this one's for the nerds: An excerpt from a new book on Gödel, Einstein, and Time.

Tuesday, December 14, 2004

The Year in Ideas

A run through of the NY Times Magazine peice The Year in Ideas. The whole collection is freaking amazing and is fully deserving of your time.

---

Think your PGP-encrypted SSL-tunneled firewall-ed email is safe? Think again. The lead off article (by alphabetical order) is about accoustic eavesdropping on computer keyboards by associating the sound a specific key makes with a specific sound. Apparently they're recognizably different, and this is huge: no matter how much security you stack into the wires, if your broadcasting your communique in a single-sound for single-letter tappa-tap, you might as well say what you're typing out loud. Of course the challenge now is to develop secure keyboards that randomize their sounds.

Kudos to the researcher for 'thinking outside the box.' The scary part is that this is almost certainly something the NSA/CIA has already thought of, and I'm sure they've had these sort of bugs for years. Let's hear it for closed government research. woo.

---

This is fucking brilliant and the best (only?) use for a camera-phone I've seen to date by a million miles: Using Camera-phones to scan bar codes of food or other retail products. Scan the code, find out where your food is coming from. Is the farm organic? Has it burned tons of fossil fuels travelling half way around the world? What's the processing history? It's information overload, but it's also a huge weapon in consumer awareness. Huge.

---

What's the best way to skip a rock? This is a really fun piece that I'm looking forward to reading in Nature. A group of Frenchies have taken a theoretical and experimental look at the mechanics of rock skipping. This reminds me of Feynman's flying plate-emblem problem. Feynman's numbercrunching ended up making it's way into his QED work, if I recall, and I don't think this rock skipping mechanics work is as useless as the researcher claims--I could definitely see this research leading to new ways of landing planes (or spaceships) in the ocean with minimized violence.

---

There's a piece full of interesting ideas on fogey gadgetry. The looming baby-boomer retirement makes this gadgetry the most marketable of all.

---

Debunking Photoshop Fakery: Debunked. While the Dartmouth prof who's developing the algorithm is doing some neat work, there's a glaring lack of insight into the meat of problem on his part. Once developed and released, frauders will have open access to his software, and can test their products for believability. This is nothing more than a tiny step in a classic arms-race . Within a month "believability" software would start showing up.

An extended problem with this writeup is that it is delaying people suspicions: a photograph is not proof. The soon people understand that the better.

---

Tangentially, I also learned the origin of the word robot: "When [Karel] Capek's brother, Josef, coined the word for the automatons in the play 'R.U.R.,' he derived it from the Czech word robota, meaning 'slave labor.' "

---

The Employable Liberal Arts Major raises some questions that I've been pondering lately as I drown in engineering professionalism (and wonder why I took such 'flakey' courses at Deep Springs.) Anthony Marx, president of Amherst College, reminds me:
"To dilute the power of the liberal arts with premature professionalism will deprive our society of the thoughtful leadership it needs." If they have the luxury of time, he said, students should "go deeper into the liberal arts, because that is the seed corn of an intellectual life and informed citizenship." After all, college is breathlessly short, and the American working life increasingly long. How many professionals think back fondly to those industry-specific lingo-training courses of their undergraduate days?
Yeah, I'm totally going to be in school for at least another decade. Screw the real world, I'm working on me leadership needs. hehe.

---

The FanWing is undoubtedly one of the biggest things to hit aviation since the helicopter. Basically it uses a Mississippi-style paddle-wheel to push air over the wing and create lift without high speeds, enabling it to fly at car-like speeds and take off on shorter stretches. It uses less gas too, if the article is be believed. Really cool.

---

A Danish company has bioengineered Land-Mine-Detecting Plants that turn red in the presence of nitrogen dioxide. If it works (not much room for error here), it would be a suitable gesture to revive some of our rusting warplanes to carpet-bomb-plant south-east asia. Flower power.

---

Welcome to the world of sonocytology: amplifying the natural vibrations of cells to 'listen' to them. Changes is this vibration can be correlated to cell-death, growth, multiplication, and thereby presumably cancer. Pretty freekin' cool.

---

The divide between Professionals and Amateurs is fading fast.

---

The Singable National Anthem: "It's no small detail that the song's highest note -- the one most people can't reach -- is the word 'free,' as in, 'land of the freeeeeeeeee.'" Mmmm...symbolism.

---

Modern warfare is apparently more similar to the finessed strategy of soccer than all-American gridiron football. You mean you can't just form a blocking wall and run through Afghanistan and win the game? Go figure.

---

Even though they're now owned by Unilever, Ben and Jerry's haven't forgotten their tree-huger roots. They've apparently developed a Thermoaccoustic Freezer which uses sounds waves to compress (or rather, expand) the air in a room filled with inert gas to cool it without using harmful chemical refrigerants. Really neat-o. Ben and Jerry's is actually sold at 7-11 here in Lund, which is crazy and awesome at the same time. It's one of two pilot locations in the whole country from what I've heard. But I've noticed that pints are NOT made from the bleach-free paper that I've seen in American pints, which is both odd and a shame. Unilver-ization has begun.

---

Virtual Autopsies using MRI and CT technology. Seeing as the persons dead, I guess you can use all the radioactive tracers you want. Woo-hoo! Oh wait...to get around the body I guess you'd need a working heart...hmmm. I wonder if you can do a tracer injection and then manually drive the heart through a few cycles. Martin?

---

Virtual Sketch Artist uses Darwinian permutations to help witnesses have a go with subtle variations of their description. They talk about the effects of memory, but I still fear that the suggested permutations would guide a user unwillingly. Perhaps multiple runs could sort that out? Interesting none the less.

---

And last but not least, it appears that moisture is no longer the essence of wetness. An impressive year.

---

They also ran an interview with Stephen Hawking, which is full of brilliant bits through understandable brevity. His commentary on America, Mars, et al is right on, in my opinion. But the best part:

Q: "What is your I.Q.?"
A: "I have no idea. People who boast about their I.Q. are losers."

Monday, December 13, 2004

Shakespeare

Isaac tipped me off about Shakespeare's "Love's Labours Lost," about swearing an oath to scholarship, including fasting and avoiding contact with women for three years. Sounds awfully familiar. I'm really surprised that I've never heard of it before, and that it didn't show up once in the scores of Deep Springs application essays I read. (Don't get me started on Thoreau...) Has anyone read it? I know I know people who've guzzled down the complete works...is it worth a read? Erik?

Isaac also sent me a link to an article about Keanu Reeves' 1995 performance as Hamlet in Winnepeg. Isaac, being the Keanu fan he is, must have loved it. I found it to be a hilariously absurd tale of journalistic obsession. Anywho.

Check out this awesome NY Times Magazine peice: The Year in Ideas. I'm throwing together a run through of my favorites, with commentary, but they're all very deserving of a read. Coming later tonight.

Friday, December 10, 2004

Should Have Been a Cowboy

The west, young man, haven't you been told?
California's full of women, whiskey and gold.
- Toby Keith

Studying for finals like woah. Never said there would be any frequency to any of these updates...

Tuesday, December 07, 2004

Putting the "Pseudo-" in Pseudo-Random

This is not quite as cool as Ben Mezrich's book 'Bringing Down the House', which chronicles the escapdes of the MIT blackjack team in Vegas, but my brother linked me to a short article about a group in Britain that used lasers to gauge the speed of the roulette ball to make millions. This type of gadgetry is strictly illegal according to Mezrich, so I'm surprised they will be keeping their money. Nonetheless, clever ways of shaving away at the razor thin probabilities in gambling will always earn top honors from me, the more absurd the method the better.

Sunday, December 05, 2004

Fox 'does' Sweden

OK, now it's personal. Fox News recently (11/26) did a report from nearby Malmö, a large city here in southern Sweden, right across the water from Copenhagen, titled Swedes Reach Muslim Breaking Point. A full-page editorial in Sydsvenskan, a major swedish daily, brought the piece to my attention, and searching the Fox News site I found two related pieces from late October, Where the Busses Won't Go and The Swedish Way.

The piece is part of series about the Muslim population in Europe, and while I haven't seen the video coverage due to lacking bandwidth in my chateau, I feel I have enough material to throw a shit-fit just based upon the articles and the Swedish newspaper report.

Here's the Fox money shot:

I'm working on a series on Muslims in Europe and just returned from Malmo, Sweden, a city with a large population of immigrants. During interviews the Swedes would not say anything negative. Doctors, police chiefs, and teachers were all extremely diplomatic in their choice of words. It was only after a long while that they would start to say what they thought, that the city could not handle such rapid immigration, that it was not able to absorb or integrate the immigrants. I interviewed one nurse, then talked with her for a while off-camera, where she said that she was actually afraid to come to work because sometimes people in the emergency room would yell and become physically abusive in their demands for rapid treatment. Her eyes got wide. She said "it is not the Swedish way" to behave like that. So I got the cameraman Barnaby and interviewed her again.


I should take a page from this guys playbook and go running around Iraq asking people if they thought things where under control. If people told me no, I could just ignore them, writing them off as paranoid and not really saying what they thought. Then finally when I found someone who agreed with me I could interview them for my article.

Simply put, this is the height of journalistic irresponsibility: going somewhere with a preconceived notion of how things are (there are muslims, things must be chaotic and criminal) and then searching out that story rather than reporting the situation as it exists. As Sydsvenskan reported [translated]:

Despite the fact that Steve Harrigan traveled all the way from the US to Malmö and Rosengård, he didn't take the time to talk to a single one of those people he refers to as 'hating illiterates.' Muslims are simply depicted generally, without names or identities. They are, simply put, not human.


Yes, there is a huge immigrant population in southern Sweden, and yes there are a lot of kinks that need ironing out, but the matter is currently getting a lot of attention and making progress. It's an integration problem like any other, and like the swedish blog JKL reports [translated],
For those who are concerned about what is happening in Sweden, there are many aspects that need to be considered as part of any explanation, not the least of which is that the problem is not so much muslim--but Swedish.

Sweden has been living peacefully as a terribly homogenous population forever, and the whole blond-hair-blue-eyes thing is more than just a stereotype--50 years ago it was pretty much true. But these days more and more Swedes are named Carlos and Mohammed, and acceptance isn't coming overnight. Especially not if you blame everything on Muslims. I have my own developed opinion of how the problem will eventually be solved, but I'll save that for some other post.

The Fox News piece is clearly a cog in a well-oiled machine working to further establish the muslim/islam - terrorist/criminal word association. The muslim-terror association is the next chapter in the black-thug association perpetuated by the news coverage of the 90's (as shown in Bowling for Columbine). Beyond the inaccuracies and misrepresentations, this type of reporting is terribly destructive and brutally irresponsible. I realize that this is Fox's specialty and that the same shit-fit could be thrown in response to any one of their reports, but this time they've hit too close to home.

The icing on the cake: A looming banner-ad reminding me to WATCH BILLY GRAHAM. (check local listings). Lovely.

Below are some comments lifted from readers of Dhimmi Watch, which claims to have broken the story before Fox:

"Tear gas, clubbings, trip to airport, back to the sandbox.......illiterate lizards."

"My advice to Europeans --- send in the National Guard. Crush them. No group should be allowed this much power."

"Sweden was such a beautiful peaceful country, with such lovely people, a neanderthalic blood-cult should be allowed nowhere near it."


Amazing. Journalism has consequences. I am eagerly awaiting my shipment of James Wolcott's 'Attack Poodles and Other Media Mutants: The Looting of the News in a Time of Terror' now more than ever, despite the lame pop-lefty title.

Thursday, December 02, 2004

How I Spent My Summer Vacation

A hat tip to James Walcott, for an interesting view of the Iraqi deathscape. Sounds like an iraqi could make good money as a taxi-driver though....or a kidnapper. What says, erik? Wanna kidnap me and sell me back to Sweden for a couple hundred grand? I'll give you 60/40.

Rumors were going around Deep Springs that Graeme Wood was working as a DHL delivery man in northern Iraq last fall....I'm not sure wether to expect or doubt that he's still there. War tourism?

Cyberkenetics

So I just found this article discussing the current state of computer-brain interaction, following new developments at Cyberkenetics. Once again, incredible.....for good, but also for DARPA.

So while I follow these sorts of developments very closely, the Illichian in me is very disturbed by pages such as this.

Transhumanism

Today I found an interesting couplet of links. Political Theory Daily posts dozens of links a day and made my head spin, but I'm including it exactly because it makes my head spin: there's a staggering amount of interesting reads collected, and visiting the site is a cold reminder of all the interesting questions in the world and the fact that a persons intellectual energies are finite--sometimes you have to just say no, and for me this is one of those times.

Instead, I'm going to put my energy into Sci Tech Daily, a science copy of Arts & Letters Daily. I'm going to add both of them to the sidebar ("blogroll").

Through the latter I ended up at www.betterhumans.com, a site devoted to promoting transhumanism (it seems as though this has become the definite word for the concept, beating out post-humanism, cyborg, etc.). I read two thought provoking columns there, Human Enhancement on the Agenda by James Hughes, and Is Transhumanism the World's Most Dangerous Idea? by Nick Bostrom, a "British Academy Research Fellow" at Oxford, formerly of Yale.

I started writing a commentary of the pieces, but it wasn't happening. Instead I'm just going to discuss the ideas generally. Transhumanism is coming, and I have no idea how the world is going to receive it. And I feel it's one thing to support enabling technology that allows disabled persons to regain control of their life, but it's another to advocate for over-enabling technology, where humans recieve upgrades. I feel as though these guys don't know what they're asking for. What will become of life as we know it? I don't want to live in that world, I just want to live as a human being. As Francis Fukuyama says, "transhumanists are just about the last group that I'd like to see live forever."

The conflict here is at the very heart of the oldest written word, the Epic of Gilgamesh. You can't escape death, nor should you. As Camus so eloquently once put it, "in order to exist just once in the world it's necessary never to exist again." [xxxxxxxx] Death is part of life, without it life is nothing, and so on.

To continue this idea of embracing humanism, in a class titled "Literature and Philosophy of Love" that I took at Deep Springs, I wrote a short paper on Ovid's Pygmallion myth as deeply tragic and the very essence of what love isn't. Some excerpts.

Pygmalion is "blessed" with an incarnation of his ivory girl, his realized ideal, which is free from the imperfections of natural creation.
...
love is most present in the incongruent interactions between two lovers where their difference of being is most accented.
...
To draw a parallel to the physical/mathematical duality in science, these surprises are quite like surface texture found in the physical world. Without texture, there would be no friction, and without friction, interactions would be severely limited. Objects would only be able to transfer energy through collisions. Because of friction, we can touch, we can walk, and the surface of the Earth refuses to level itself out into one eternally flat surface. There is no texture in mathematics, just as there are no surprises in ideal love. Friction releases energy as heat into the interacting bodies. Appropriately, scientists actually understand very little about the details of friction.


I feel that an idea like love exists in that humanity of imperfection, the inclusion of something beyond oneself ("the other" for all you psychoanalysis types). My favorite part of Gabriel Garcia Marquez's Love in the Time of Cholera was the bathtub scene in the first part of the book, where Marquez bombards the reader with all these harsh, inorganic, yuckities--most memorably the smell of stale urine on an unwashed toilet. These are the things that make us human. Or rather, in this already cleaned up version of humanity, those are the parts of our humanity that we have not yet escaped. The western toilet really is a invention of incredible significance. Robin Williams even chimes into all this in Good Will Hunting with his discussion of his wife's farting habit. I'm a big fan of humanity. I don't want to be perfect, I don't want to be a lithium barbie doll.

So...how do I defend my interest in neuroelectrophysiology and artificial limbs? Well, that's a question of enabling, not 'over-enabling'. I feel that assistive technology will be one of science's greatest gift to humanity over the next century, eliminating the vast majority of physical disabilities. But I also see the evil twin of this sort of technology, namely the military applications and the 'culture of humanity' that it threatens through over-enabling.

It's something that I'm wrestling with. I put some stock in the 'people don't want to be better than well' argument, but that doesn't solve the military question. Time will tell.

I'm going to conclude with a reprint of an email I serialized last fall.

---
Howdy y'all,

There is a very interesting article summarizing a recent report by the President's Council on Bioethics: Beyond Therapy: Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Human Happiness [warning: 350 pages, thus the summary article]. Yes, the council is spiced with some unfortunate Bushist 'academics,' but for the most part consists of highly respectable researchers and scientific figures. (Michael Gazzaniga among them, whose 'Cognitive Neuroscience' textbook is within arms reach as I write this.) [Edit: I'll admit to not knowing that much about the other figures, and the articles above do sound damning, but then again I generally disagree with the stance of the authors.]

While the article focuses mostly on gene manipulation, there are many examples of technologically assisted over-enabling that are much more imminent and less 'controversial.' Many of these things are only a matter of time, and do not involve any rogue researching--they simply have legitimate goals that can be misused (terribly).

A good example that I'm fond of discussing is artificial sight, essentially the act of connecting a digital camera to the visual cortex. Sure, it's a blessing for the blind. It is also immensely desirable for military special forces. Imagine your 'human' troops battling troops with zoom-capable, infra-red capable artificial eyes. Such a 'high-tech' troop is going to be on every general's wish-list. In the end, who isn't going to want one of these installed? Where to go from here? Is it possible to promote a culture of humanness? Where will it end? It's going to be difficult (I'm not saying you should) to tell blind individuals to forgo the research. Is there any way to have to best of both worlds, help the blind and not make this the next Botox?

The article makes a good point of the following: "persuading people to do anything that might make them 'better than well' is like persuading a cat to swim. That is why so many people take up exercise only after their heart attack. Most people will do almost anything to become well, and practically nothing to become better than well." People aren't getting gratuitous hearing aids, this is true. But that's a small jump. Imagine qualitative improvements of 'life,' such as night vision and 100X zoom at will. People might not want to be 'better than well', but what about an offer of great?

Many of you have received this sermon from me before. Apologies.

So anyways, read the article. It'll make ya think.

human for the time being,
johan